Na'im Akbar said it best: "There is no event which does not have simultaneous and systematic impact on other systems of existence. The body does not even experience tension that is not simultaneously registered in the mental and spiritual spheres."
I thought I had moved into a cause that did not involve men's issues. When my friend was picked up by immigration and he brought me many other immigrants in even worse circumstances than he was in - when I realized that the way detained immigrants were being treated in this country violated everything that I had grown up believing my country stood for, I thought I had an immigration issue on my hands.
Then, out of the first few immigrants targeted by ICE that came my way all were men, 2 had lived existences that seriously suggested domestic slavery and one had been deported on the word of a pissed off girlfriend and a domestic assault charge that was never proven.
Then the new director of DHS, Janet Napolitano came up with this gem: "Serious felons deserve to be in the prison model, but there are others. There are women. There are children." So Ms Napolitano - are you saying that all felons are men or that women are like children and are never felons? What exactly are you saying there?! I'm not even sure who was insulted on that one - men or women - but I know it was an insult to whatever teacher had Ms Napolitano in his logic class.
Then a young man told me of his ordeal being deported from this country 10 years ago, being separated from his daughters, being told by the judge when he asked who would raise his children that the government would and BAM! - suddenly I was right back in the same arena I've been fighting in for the last 19 years - men's rights. Good grief, people - could ya switch it up a little? This is getting old!
I have said this so many times, but here it goes again: Any belief that a person is superior or inferior due to an accident of birth, whether that be one of race, religion, gender, sexual orientation or any other bloody thing human kind can come up with to discriminate against is holding the door open for prejudice and bigotry. If you want to end prejudice . . . stop inviting it in to sit at the table! As long as it is okay to discriminate against anyone for the way he or she is born the bigots and haters of this world win. You don't have to like people of all groups. There are some I'm not overly fond of, but that doesn't give me the right to persecute them or deny them their rights. Now if you move over into the arena of chosen actions - that is a whole different ball game, but don't tell me that only men are abusers or that Mexican immigrants are more inclined to commit crimes and you have the facts and statistics to prove it . . . don't even go there! I'm old enough to remember when the "scientific evidence" pointed to how incapable women were at certain tasks and how inferior and criminally inclined blacks were. I remember when William Shockley's dissertations on eugenics were actually considered valid. Changing the targeted group does not validate any message of hate.
I am not interested in hearing the reasons why in one particular case it is the exception. I have heard them all already. I'm 60 freakin' years old people and I've heard it so many times by now I could tell it to you! Just give me the group you want to hate - men, Mexicans, gays - any group - go ahead. Give me your reasons. I guarantee that they will be the same bloody reasons that were pushed in the 60s as why blacks are naturally subservient or women are naturally weak. I promise you - the targets change, but the tactics and justification remains the same.
You want to end hatred? You want to end bigotry? You want to bring some compassion and caring to this world? Then stop your bloody hatin'!!! And yes, I am yelling! I am so sick of perfectly intelligent people presenting me with the same sorry-assed bullshit and expecting me to swallow it like it's the finest chocolate. It's BULLSHIT! Dress it up however you want. Give it all the "scientifically obtained statistics" you want to prove your point that in this case there really is proof that this one group is somehow bad or less because they were born male or Hispanic or maybe sexually confused or whatever your issue is, but don't pretend you aren't contributing to the oppression of mankind in doing so. Don't think you can demonize one select group and not harm humanity as a whole. Don't sit there and say you care about people and you are doing this for the benefit of all. And don't expect me to agree with you, because that is just insulting. It suggests that you think I'm stupid enough to buy what you are serving up and honey, I just ain't that gullible!
Do you think I'm doing something noble - sticking up for the underdog? No honey - there's nothing noble here. When injustice and cruelty become the order of the day no one is safe. Think back to the French Revolution - those who started and fed the hatred eventually lost their own heads to the violence. In a world where justice can be bent to suit the latest agenda and human rights are optional no one is safe. I'm fighting for my own welfare, nothing more. Na'im Akbar said it best.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Deborah,
ReplyDeleteI really like your post, I see this everyday. I work in a clinic that provides care to the uninsured, homeless, and immigrant population, and pre-conceived notions are placed upon these people without regard to the individual.We as a whole cannot control the rantings and ravings of those who proclaim to be "superior," or those who are just ignorant to the real facts, or even those who just tend to walk away because "it doesn't affect me," but we can continue to stand together for change and equal justice for all as our Constitution proclaims. Change is not always welcome, but it is needed!
My friend, you've written to me about the disheartening lack of help offered by the families of the men you're helping; the times their attitude seems to be, "Deborah is taking care of it so I don't need to become involved." The "someone else is handling it so I don't need to" syndrome. And you've pointed out to me that Americans in general take so many critically important things for granted: the Consitution, for one. We think it will always be there for us, that there must be SOMETHING in the Constitution that will protect us from all evil. The Constitution will always be there, right?
ReplyDeleteA few days ago I watched a documentary on ESPN about Muhammad Ali's last championship fight (against Larry Holmes in 1980). The documentary covered the 2-3 months prior to the fight, and the fight itself. Ali hadn't fought in a while and at the start of the film he was badly out of shape. He lost something like 30 pounds in the last two months, died his grey hair black, etc. He LOOKED like the Muhammad Ali of the 1960s. But he wasn't. Not even close.
His fight doctors pleaded with him not to take the fight. He was 38 years old. He hadn't fought in too long a period. These doctors were already recognizing the early signs of the Parkinson's Disease that now afflicts him. They begged him not to fight, they begged him to call it a career. The risks were too great.
But on at least 5-6 occasions during the film Ali said (paraphrasing here) "I'll be fine. They warned me before the Sonny Liston fight, they warned me before the Joe Frazier fight, they told me there was no way I could beat George Foreman. I won all those fights. Every time I go into the ring I find a way to win. It's always there and it will be there this time against Larry Holmes."
Sports fans know the sad outcome. Ali was humiliated that night against Larry Holmes. He was not just defeated, he was beaten up. The beating was so bad that during the fight Larry Holmes was begging the referee to stop the bout; he didn't want to keep beating up Ali. It was excruciating to watch.
There can come a time when the Constitution won't be there for us, too. I know it's unimaginable but it's true. If we don't keep watch, if we don't guard our freedoms, if we continue to surrender our freedom to the government, there's the chance the government will make the Constitution meaningless.
And we know from experience when one of us is not free, none of us is free.
Keep up the fight, my friend.